Book Or Movie? || A Comparative Review Of The Hate U Give by Angie Thomas.

comparative review of the hate u give book movie desire uba
4 minutes read

After last year’s intense reading, The Hate U Give felt like the best bet to start off 2019.The movie adaptation was definitely the most emotion- grabbing movie I saw in 2018 and its book, one of the most popular on the #Bookstagram community. It obtains its semi-eponymous name from the acronym by Tupac Shakur, THUG LIFE (The Hate U Give Little Infants F***s Everyone).

I went on an all- out spree searching for the book but I simply could not find it. Eventually, I was gifted the book and decided that it’d be my first read in 2019.

The lead character, Starr Carter is a 16 year old black girl leading a seeming double life. As an offspring of a teen mom turned nurse and an ex- drug dealer living in the fictional ‘ghetto’, Garden Heights, she struggles to juggle life as she attends a predominantly white prep school and with her presumably beautiful relationship with her white boyfriend, Chris.

The story, in both adaptations, tells of the killing (and its aftermath) of her best friend and presumed drug dealer, Khalil, who was shot by a white policeman.

The Hate U Give, in general, is a narrative that isn’t afraid to portray a specific story – a truthful and important story.

Starr and her siblings grew up with parents who wanted much better for their children than they had, and they struggled to ascertain that while letting their progeny understand the reality in the world- despite the fact that we should be equal, racial injustice still exists and they needed to acknowledge that before working against it. Starr had witnessed the shooting and death of her other best friend, Natasha, when they were much younger which set for a much deeper story with that of of Khalil.

After this event, Starr had to make difficult choices regarding how, why and when to share her story to preserve the memory of her friend which was being tarnished due to his brief history as a drug dealer ,while ensuring the safety of her family.

READ ALSO: BOOK REVIEW|| ‘Are We The Turning Point Generation?’ by Chude Jideonwo

Cast Versus Characters

The book, The Hate U Give, had well developed characters and due to the fact that I had already seen the movie, I had faces and emotions to bring the book to life. The casting was truly in sync with most of the characters in the book.

However, two physical standouts were Seven, Starr’s brother as his signature locs were not a part of the movie and Maya, her friend,who was supposed to be Chinese but was played by a mixed race actress.

Issa Rae was the on-screen adaptation of April Ofrah, a levelheaded activist and lawyer who voluntarily represented Starr. She didn’t quite portray her worded counterpart but she did a more profound job than the character in the book.

the hate u give indepth book, movie review

Scenes Versus Screen

It is typically difficult to have a movie that satisfies better than a book because of the nuances the book always possesses.

A large percentage of the scenes, such as Chris’ meeting with Starr’s dad as well as Khalil’s shooting were excellently executed but some scenes. However, some critical scenes that literally made the movie the force it is, like the epic moment where Sekani, an eight year old, took up a gun, were missing in the book and vice-versa.

the-hate-u-give-quotes

The Issue Of The Missing Character

In the opening scene of the movie, Khalil and Starr met at a party and there was a shooting but nothing else was said about it so it’s assumed that nothing drastic happened there. The book definitely proves this wrong.

Someone was killed and his brother, DeVante turned out to be one of the more prominent and inspiring supporting characters in the book. It comes off as very odd that DeVante and the incident were not mentioned in the movie.

READ ALSO: 3 + 1 THINGS YOU DESERVE IN LIFE, SO ASK NOW!

The Hate U Give is an intense story. Its book tells a more indepth narrative concerning what it could feel like struggling to stand for the right thing when you are part of an oppressed sect. It tells the story of love, friendship, family and strength.

One thing I absolutely hated about this book was the writing tempo which was intensely YA. Adults who want to read this book might get irritated at certain points (like I did) because the writing felt too laid back.

The movie, on the other hand, focuses on the blatant injustice that comes with being (and living) black as individuals, a family and community.

The Hate U Give was an emotionally jarring experience that gives a wake-up call I which I believe we all need.

OVERALL RATING

Book: 4.5 / 5(This could have been a 5, but I hated the YA language.)

Movie: 4.5/ 5

Have you read any book this year? Seen or heard about The Hate U Give? Which do you prefer- Books Or Movies?

Thank you so much for reading!

VENI. VIDI. AMAVI.

DESIRE.

Enjoyed this? Kindly share:

10 thoughts on “Book Or Movie? || A Comparative Review Of The Hate U Give by Angie Thomas.

  1. Hey Desire, lovely write up as always, you gave done justice to an awesome story and given those if us who are yet to take in the pages of the book. I’d be sure to pick up a copy on my next journey to the book store. In all of this though, I’d like to talk about something I feel still constricts our freedom, something of our own doing. Something that sucks the life out of truth and allows hatred to keep breeding amongst us, something that holds growth by the neck till it breaths it’s last. Something we call “snitching ” . This dastardly act from time old has allowed so many mean and treacherous men and women to walk free after committing some unthinkable acts. We knowing let them walk free in fear of what they may do to us and our families, we let them walk free because we are “mumu” beneficiaries to their unsavoury acts, we let them walk free in the name of brotherhood and family. We let them walk free because our conscience does not see the light of day anymore. I think till we begin to open up about our vices as a community and cast out this supposed untouchable people, we will never truly be free. God bless

  2. Very very very good review. I cannot decide which I prefer. To watch the adaptation of a book into a movie first before reading a book, or to read the book first.
    Sadly enough I haven’t heard of your book or the movie until now.

  3. I watched the movie and had all my emotions running…. Happiness, Anger, Sadness, Tears… Definitely an eye opening story and Starr was amazing. Love how the movie ended… I screamed and cried when Starr’s little brother held a gun to the bad guys, Clear example of Thuglife… Not sure I’ll still want to read the book but I’ll be nice to place a face to the characters in the book.

  4. I absolutely loved the book which i read before watching the movie adaptation and i still feel the movie didnt do enough justice to how amazing the book is.. Your review on both is great
    obennyne.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

error

Enjoying this post? Kindly share with others :)